Myths versus facts
Ten tidy ideas, and the official wording that will not tidy them
A first look at Mallard often wants one number. The museums offer more than one, and they are all official.
Myth
Mallard has one official peak speed, so 125 and 126 can be averaged.
Official wording
Mallard 75 records a claimed peak of 125 mph before Essendine, and a subsequent examination that suggested 126 mph for less than a mile. The same page also opens with 126mph on 3 July 1938. This desk does not invent a third speed. [source]
Myth
The 126 on the plaque is how the speed was published on the day.
Official wording
“The plaque on the side of Mallard showing the peak speed as 126 mph was fitted to the locomotive after the war.” Gresley declined to mention the suggested 126, “as the distance was for less than a mile.” [source]
Myth
Mallard holds the overall railway speed record.
Official wording
A Science Museum Group copy says “the speed record only applies to steam locomotives,” because a German experimental electric railcar “had achieved 130mph in 1903.” “That record still stands” is a steam-locomotive record. [source]
Myth
The German record it beat is unnamed, so 05 002 should be dropped.
Official wording
Mallard 75 gives the May 1935 German steam record as 124.5 mph and does not name the locomotive on the page re-opened for this rebuild. The Science Museum Group copy names “German locomotive 05 002.” Both wordings are kept, and 05 002 is not added to the museum page that does not use it. [source]
Myth
114 mph was a world steam record.
Official wording
Gresley authorised a bid “to try and beat the (then) British steam record of 114 mph held by the LMS.” This desk treats 114 mph only as that British steam record. [source]
Myth
The Coronation headboard in later photographs is the 1938 record train.
Official wording
The 2009 and 2010 photographs show “The Coronation” on the nose. The official run is described with a dynamometer car, Barkston, Stoke Bank and Essendine. The headboard is not used here as the record train. [source]
Myth
Gresley’s title is one official phrase, so Chief Engineer can be silently edited to Chief Mechanical Engineer.
Official wording
Mallard 75 calls him Chief Engineer at the LNER in the body, and Chief Mechanical Engineer in a caption. The fact sheet and a 2026 display also use Chief Mechanical Engineer. Both titles stay as written. [source]
Myth
A precise figure on a photograph caption can be used to settle 125 and 126.
Official wording
A precise figure on a photograph caption is not used on this site, and it is not taken from the official museum pages used here. [source]
Myth
Mallard was withdrawn and then simply appeared in the Great Hall.
Official wording
It retired in 1963, was preserved in 1964 by the British Transport Commission, entered the collection in 1975, was restored to working order between 1982 and 1988, and ran a limited number of times until 1989. [source]
Myth
The 130 mph Duddington believed in, or the September 1939 run, is the official record.
Official wording
Those official almosts — a driver’s belief, and a planned run prevented by the Second World War — are not used to overwrite the 125, the 126, or the 1903 electric figure. [source]
Enjoyed this desk on 125, 126, and a steam record that still stands in its official category?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next railways.im site get built.